A thoughtful and detailed analysis of the numbers behind Y Combinator’s seed funding program, as compared with a typical seed-stage angel investment:
YC argues their advice and connections are worth this premium. I respectfully disagree. Advice and connections for even idea-stage entrepreneurs are easy to find with a little initiative, and if you don’t have that, you’ll fail as an entrepreneur. YC’s connections, Demo Day, and brand are indeed value-added, but it’s hard to argue they’re worth ten times an angel and free advice and connections.
YC supporters say their teams are little more than first-time entrepreneurs with ideas. That’s generally true, but YC’s hackers are able to build most prototypes in 3 months anyway. Is it worth 3 months working by yourself to get 10x a better deal? I think so.
I can only assume that similar arguments exist with respect to our friends at LaunchBox Digital and TechStars.